clock menu more-arrow no yes

Filed under:

Is LMJ Heading for Tommy John Surgery?

New, 131 comments

Signs seem to indicate that Lance McCullers Jr. has been pitching through an injury that may put him on the shelf for 2019

League Championship Series - Houston Astros v Boston Red Sox - Game Two Photo by Elsa/Getty Images

As Boston and Houston were preparing to get underway last night a bit of news dropped from a freelance reporter about one of the Astros key pitchers:

For context, this reporter was the first to report that Joe Smith was signing with the Astros.

This tweet immediately invoked images of Lance tapping on his forearm during a game at Dodgers stadium this season before getting pulled early and being sent back to Houston for evaluation. This was particularly concerning because symptoms of elbow injuries often appear in the forearm first. However, team doctors would surmise that he had received the injury while swinging the bat and not pitching, and the fan base would heave a sigh of relief.

Lance would go on the shelf for a couple of months at that point and have a couple of setbacks in his recovery, but all indications were that he would return in time for the postseason, probably out of the bullpen. When that proved true and it became evident that neither his command or velocity had dropped everything seemed to be alright. Indeed, he would go on to pitch 5 postseason innings, striking out 4.

But it seemed that that was not the whole story.

After last night’s exit from the playoffs, Lance would reveal he had been pitching through an injury but did not reveal the full extent. “I’ve definitely been pitching through some stuff and that’s all going to be figured out here in the next couple weeks,” McCullers said. “I was pitching through a lot of stuff, a lot of guys were playing through a lot of stuff. My only goal was to win the World Series, I had no other intention and no other goals. We’ll figure it out moving forward.”

He was pressed on whether he would require surgery and would only reply that it would all be figured out.

There was also this cryptic remark from Bregman:

This all seems to be pointing to a much more serious injury than fans had been led to believe. Of course, this also brings up memories from earlier in the season when Houston would regularly obfuscate injuries to players. While it’s understandable that they want to assess an injury without the media running with wild speculations, this still appears to be a frustrating pattern with the team.

I’m sure we’ll be finding out within the next month or two exactly what will be happening with McCullers’ elbow. But if it’s TJS you can probably count him out for 2019, creating a big hole in the starting rotation. Though there are options at hand, it will be difficult to replace the dynamic young hurler on the staff.

No matter which way it goes, let’s hope for a recovery process that will allow Lance to regain his form sooner rather than later and return to a dominant rotation for Houston.