clock menu more-arrow no yes

Filed under:

Busting out in the Divisional Round: Alex Rodriguez and Jeff Bagwell

New, 6 comments

Story after story after story have been written in the past week about Alex Rodriguez' playoff redemption. For a player as maligned as Rodriguez, truly positive press can be hard to come by. After a season of high expectations for his team, the Yankee third baseman thriving outside of the spotlight- free agent signees Mark Teixeira, AJ Burnett and CC Sabathia, the resurgent Derek Jeter and their new baseball palace have stolen headlines that used to belong to A-Rod. If the result of this relative lack of exposure is the success we've witnessed over the first few games of the playoffs, then maybe Rodriguez could use some of that $300 million contract to force the NY beat writers to focus on Jerry Hairston, Jr. and Brett Gardner in 2010.

Besides the lessening of external pressure on the slugger, the lineup the Yankees have fielded this season is much stronger than those in playoff years past. Outside of 2004, his playoff performances have been well below his career averages. It's tough to judge a player based off of fewer than 35 AB, but it's the nature of the beast playing in New York, on baseball's biggest stage.

Jeff Bagwell never had to deal with the New York media, or the ire of the baseball public during his illustrious career. After four failed attempts to escape the first round the playoffs, Bagwell and the Astros finally managed to lay their collective demons to rest by beating the Atlanta Braves in the 2004 NLDS. Bags would see extended playoff ABs for the first time in his career, and he responded by posting a stupendous "triple-slash" of .318/.400/.682 in 22 ABs. No longer would he be forced to head into yet another off season coming off of tepid October performances.

Was there anything special about that October as compared to 1997, '98, '99 or 2001 (which in fairness was a solid, albeit short, postseason for Jeff)?

1997:

Position Player wOBA
C Bradley .305
1B Bags .428
2B Craig .410
3B S. Berry/Spiers .316/.404
SS Bogar/Ricky .315/.302
LF Gonzo .320
CF Hidalgo .373
RF Abreu .319

 

1998:

Position Player wOBA
C Ausmus .318
1B Bags .422
2B Craig .406
3B Berry .387
SS Gutierrez .301
LF Alou .416
CF Everett .359
RF Bell .373

 

1999:

Position Player wOBA
C Eusebio .320
1B Bags .422
2B Craig .368
3B Cammy .374
SS Bogar .294
LF Javier .374
CF Everett .416
RF Bell .296

 

Note: This season saw the likes of Daryle Ward (.336), Javier, and Matt Mieske (.333) start playoff games in the outfield. Yikes.

2001:

Position Player wOBA
C Bradley .270
1B Bags .408
2B Craig .364
3B V. Castilla .339
SS J. Lugo .303
LF Alou .397
CF Hidalgo .346
RF Lance .435

 

2004:

Position Player wOBA
C Bradley .271
1B Bags .364
2B Kent .369
3B Ensberg .321
SS Everett .313
LF Craig .349
CF Beltran .404
RF Lance .427

 

While the addition of Beltran and Kent in 2004 were huge  additions, it wasn't as if the Astros became the '27 Yankees. In fact, this was Bagwell's worst season in his career (to that point), yet he had his best postseason ever. While A Rod's mates are clearly superior in 2009 than in seasons past, the same can't truly be said of Bags' bunch in 2004. Between his and Craig's declines, and the lowest output from 3B since 1997, this was a pretty good, but not superior lineup. What surprised me was that Jeff Kent, a power hitting second baseman throughout his career, posted Biggio-like numbers at second in 2004. Lance Berkman is great....like, "play for five more seasons and punch his ticket to Cooperstown" great.

If anything, I'd chalk up their 2004 NLCS appearance to not having to face Greg Maddux, Tom Glavine, Kevin Brown, and John Smoltz, and instead facing off against Jaret Wright, John Thomson, Russ Ortiz and Mike Hampton. Wait a second...Ortiz? Hampton? Weren't they on the....this season? Damn.