Please Turn Out The Lights
I'll admit it, sure. Why not?
After Nady hit the homer and Doumit walked, I was rooting for Don Kelly to hit a 2-RBI double.
And he almost did, and he almost walked him, but then he wriggled off the hook, thanks to the major league's best shortstop going back.
Damn, I wish Kelly's liner down the line had been fair.
See, my thinking was that if Lidge had given up three in the ninth, there wouldn't be be any doubt about who most deserved the blame for tonight's loss.
Reading below, I see Garner's name, I see Everett's name (despite his double). And yeah, I see Lidge's name too, but Christ, I think it should be unanimous.
Now we're gonna hear squawking about the poor offensive showing, we're gonna hear squawking about Chad Qualls, we're gonna hear squawking about Ausmus and Everett and probably even Roger Clemens, when all the talk right now should be about our now undoubtedly failed closer.
He can't do the job anymore. I don't know why, and frankly I'm tired of speculating. But he can't, and the club needs to do whatever it is you do to old closers who can't cut the mustard.
Roundrock his ass, I suppose. Maybe trade him for a Pat Borders, or an Alan Zinter.
I wanted Lidge replaced last year, and when he came back to take the job later on, I thought that was a lousy idea, too, but I deferred--as I so often do--to management. After all, they know so much more about baseball than me. If they think Lidge has worked it out, well then, maybe he has.
Or so went my overly charitable thinking at the time.
An advocate for Lidge (and we have a few) might say that the results last year after he regained the job were inconclusive.
OK, then, lousy year, get 'em in 2007.
And then there was the double digit ERA in the Spring. Well, that "worrisome." That was the word that got tossed around. We were worried.
But frankly, it was hard to get too excited, because the regular season wasn't here.
Well now it's here, and Lidge is back to doing what he did for the greater part of last year, and for all of Spring Training: giving up untimely runs.
It'd be great if you could go back in time and retroactively take the Red Sox offer, when they were desperately trying to keep Papelbon in the rotation. I guess they didn't offer much, but then again, we aren't gonna get much when we send Lidge to Austin, either.
Amd I'm also sure that instead of making this move tomorrow, the club will draw it out for a couple months, finally installing Wheeler into the spot in which is most fit sometime in late May.
I tell you, though: they should skip the bullshit. Get over the fear that Brad Lidge is going to go and be great someplace else. Take a backup catcher for him, or a minor league first baseman. It's readily apparent that he will never be great again in Houston.
Much of 2006 was wasted vacillating over what to do in the closer's spot as Lidge failed time and time again. It's not to early to prevent that from happening in 2007, to be proactive and to prevent the past from repeating itself.
But I think they lack the guts.
45 comments
|
0 recs |
Do you like this story?
Comments
"Take a...minor league first baseman"
Yeah, Lidge sucks.
He's still got trade value
by steve @ The Crawfish Boxes on Apr 2, 2007 10:51 PM CDT reply actions
Agreeing with you...
What really sucks though is there is another win for ROY down the tubes. I mean, last year there were so many games like this and Roy still won 15 last year. This is why it is so hard for Roy to win 20 (which he has to stuff to accomplish) ~ pisses me off!
Go Astros!
SeoulStro
100% Agreement
And yes, I was secretly praying for Kelly to drive the nail in the coffin just to make the point that the lights aren't out - someone just stole the bulb.
I would send him to Round Rock...
Unfortunately, the Astros' mindset seems to be: keep sending him out there game after game, until the house has burned down. Garner said as much during his post-game press conference.
1st in a season of many disappointments...
by mswank on Apr 2, 2007 11:59 PM CDT reply actions
A comment from
"Question
When did it become okay to bat a guy with consecutive .290 OBP seasons in front of Lance Berkman and Carlos Lee?
Your other options include Morgan Ensberg (.396 in 2006), Chris Burke (.347), and Luke Scott (.426 in limited ABs).
Everett, by the way, did do better against lefties last year (.333), but Ensberg went for an insane .463."
I retract my defense of Garner a few days ago, doubting remarks from ESPN radio that Garner's on the hot seat. He probably isn't (yet), but he made a giant step tonight.
The most unforgivable issue tonight was the bonehead base running by Luke (that was probably on his own) and sending Burke home from second on the shallow single to left center. As long as we are a team that can't score much, we can't afford ANY baserunning errors!
Nope, none of that matters.
No team game is ever lost solely by one person
Oh, an have we forgotten about that 2 run Pirate homer in the tenth? Don't recall that it was Lidge who was pitching then.
Lidge
by Cola @ The Crawfish Boxes on Apr 3, 2007 1:20 AM CDT reply actions
Wheels
Round Rock
Failing that, Lidge should be moved into long-relief. There is nothing gained for anyone to keep running him out there to blow save situations. Let him work himself back into that role, if he can. It's irrelevant who closes so long as Lidge does not.
Amen To That!
It's irrelevant who closes so long as Lidge does not.Truer words were never written in the angst-ridden comments section of an Astros blog.
It only took 9 innings
There's no such thing as a "good reliever with a confidence issue." If guys can hit your stuff with consistency, you're a lousy pitcher.
by dangflagpoleinplay on Apr 3, 2007 10:25 AM CDT reply actions
I love it/hate it
Now I hate that I tried to defend him to everyone through 2006. =|
Ted Deluca
Can't step back we are already headed down
Of course I hope I eat these words.
by Burford on Apr 3, 2007 12:24 PM CDT up reply actions
9th inning woes
by Tiffany on Apr 3, 2007 11:55 AM CDT reply actions
I agree with littlevisigoth completely
Lidge tonight? RR? Starting?
Last two appearances, 2 home runs. Pence just rocked him and Nady crushed him too. The cutter looked good, the slider didn't. If the Astros are married to the arm and confident he's healthy, I've got no beef with exploring all options including starting. He shouldn't be closing.
Join me on my "Jump to Conclusions Mat". If he can throw 3-4 pitches for strikes, gives up gopher balls, strikes out folks, has decent control with the fastball (it looked pretty good last night), but only throws 92-94 (without the Gagne/Hoffman change) does that sound like a closer? Nope. Sounds like a starter to me. Closers rely on 2 great pitches, it looks like Lidge now has 3-4 good pitches and no great ones. If Brad really is the superstar the organization envisions him as, maybe he can pull the Old Smoltz Manuever. Anything but this tragic act.
by steve @ The Crawfish Boxes on Apr 3, 2007 12:28 PM CDT reply actions
actually his last two appearances were last night
2 out of 3 then
by steve @ The Crawfish Boxes on Apr 3, 2007 1:05 PM CDT up reply actions
As a starter in the Minors
I don't blame the loss on Lidge. Balls get hit, and some leave the yard when they get hit. It is a fact that a pitcher has no control of the ball after it leaves his hand. He can only try to create outs. I would only blame Lidge if he gave up a 2-run HR after walking a batter.
I will tell everyone that the fact that Lidge has given up an unreasonable amount of HRs compared to league avg due to bad luck. His avg against is great and his K/9 is great. LIDGE MAY IN FACT BE CURSED.
On what part
lol i just laugh when i read
Just the way it was the last sentence and in all caps, i thought you were joking. It kinda reminds me of the movie Hocus Pocus. Aren't curses like put on a person by a witch or something? I can understand maybe he needs a fresh start, or hes had some bad luck, a curse just seems extreme to me. Are you using the word cursed literally or just to mean hes having bad luck?
If
If we could only harness the powers of Pujols for the use of GOOD, the world would be a better place.
I will start working on a serum that
Not sure why Lidge doesn't get hurt anymore
Lidge sticking as a reliever might have been a health concern but also a reflection of his repertoire, 98 mph heat, filthy slider. I think they've gotta be open to novel solutions.
by steve @ The Crawfish Boxes on Apr 3, 2007 2:59 PM CDT up reply actions
All that said
The reason the Astros lost the game:
- was from bad RP from Lidge and Qualls.
- Manso waving Burke home with one out and Biggs coming up
- A great play and bad instincts by Everett on the liner to 2nd with 0 outs
- lack of timely hitting with men on
Garner's management:
- Everett should never hit second. It is a joke. And not funny, like a cruel mean-spirited joke little boys pull on their big sisters.
- Palmeiro should never pinch hit when Lamb is available to pinch hit. Orlando led off the ninth when Lamb was still available. That is stupid. Lamb is a GOOD hitter. He has power, gets on base, and has a good avg. Palmeiro is a situational hitter with no pop. Just believe me.
- Ausmus was in the game to hit in the 10th. Why? Can anyone tell me? He already caught 9 innings and he is the worst hitter in baseball. Quintero could have caught in the 11th. Why not Lane?
i also
waving Burke with one out and the top of the order coming up was just idiotic. i don't care what your scouting report on Chris Duffy says, you should play it safe and trust Biggio to come through for you.
i'm not taking too much from this game. i'm not saying i have 100% faith in Lidge right now, but the guys in the front office decided to stick with him and Ausmus and the rest of the team contend that he's still got the stuff to be successful, so i'm going to reserve my judgement beyond just one game. i won't wait as long to jump ship as i did last year though, and i hope neither do Tim and Phil.
by littlevisigoth on Apr 3, 2007 3:13 PM CDT up reply actions
Lidge Cursed...?
These are only for 2006
BA Against - 238, K/BB 104/36
Vs RH - 201, Vs LH - 286
BA Late and Close - 247
BA RISP - 241
BA RISP and 2 out - 220
All these numbers are solid or good except BA versus LH hitters BUT here are the home/away splits.
Inn ERA HR BB SO SLG
Home 39 6.46 9 18 47 .509
Away 37 4.00 1 18 57 .271
Almost the complete difference in performance can be attributed to the HRs given up in Minute Maid. So is Lidge just that much worse at home, is there a hang up from a previous unmentionable incident or is he cursed? And more importantly can it be fixed? I think that opportunity has passed unfortunately.
by Burford on Apr 3, 2007 2:43 PM CDT reply actions
here's painful:
I'm in the camp that thinks Lidge should be out. I hadn't though of him as a long reliever, though I'm actually warming to that idea. Arm problems would be a concern, I suppose, but what is there to lose, at this point. And to the argument that we are jumping to a conclusion too quickly, I would refer to the fact that I have felt the exact same way about Lidge for the last year, up to and including last night: fear, insecurity, a certain sweating of the palms. It's nothing new; a long tryout.
BTW
Keep up the posts.
Good Comments by Shamus
I was looking for Lamb but was ok with Palmeiro at that point. OP is pretty good at putting the ball in play and not striking out.
The play where Everett got doubled off was just an awesome defensive move by Castillo. I think less than a dozen major league 2nd basemen make that catch.
by Burford on Apr 3, 2007 4:01 PM CDT reply actions
"Heartbreak Lidge"
I'm glad he's a nice guy who's effusive and cordial with the press after he blows a lead or if they want to bring up Pujols again. That being said, I'd have no problem if he bacame a surly, insolent bastard and kept his ERA below 2.
by dangflagpoleinplay on Apr 3, 2007 4:20 PM CDT reply actions
I disagree
by bgoodwyn on Apr 3, 2007 4:37 PM CDT reply actions
Not quite with you, BG
The rest of your blog made me dizzy, by the way. I am considering asking you to do my taxes...
by dangflagpoleinplay on Apr 3, 2007 5:08 PM CDT up reply actions
Nowhere else to put this
Was really happy to see Scott get off to a good start yesterday, especially with the long fly to center. Hopefully this is nothing serious and won't have a lasting affect on his performance (he complained of lingering injuries hampering his late season performance last year).
One thing we haven't talked about
Where does he fall on the bullpen priority list now?
He didn't excel in the spring as far as I remember and, if we were to go with what's working right now, Borkowski or Rick White or (I know I'm gonna regret this) Brian Moehler should be higher on the bullpen pecking order.
Qualls has been perhaps as disappointing as Lidge in his downfall or the past year plus, although obviously in a less dramatic fashion.
by Kian on Apr 3, 2007 6:38 PM CDT reply actions
Worst Part about Lidge's Debacle on Monday
This is further evidence that NL Managers and Players have a well-written book on Lidge. Everyone has checked it out at the library including the lowly pirates. If Lidge thinks he is fine mechanically and hitting his spots and IS STILL getting jacked around, then that is a horrible sign.
by Big Puma on Apr 4, 2007 2:27 PM CDT reply actions

by 






















