2005 Draft Snapshot
I was cataloguing some minor league cards before I put them away when I realized what a large bust Ralph Henriquez has actually been.
From there, it wasn't long before my curiosity took over and I made this:
| Round | Player | Position | AVG/OBP/SLG/OPS, ERA/WHIP/K9 in 2007 | Comments |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | Brian Bogusevic | P | 4.61 1.55 7.01, mostly at High A Salem, some at AA Corpus |
Lefties take longer? |
| 1 (S'wich) | Eli Iorg | OF | .296 .350 .512 .863 at High A Salem |
Ended year in June with elbow injury |
| 2 | Ralph Henriquez | C | .185 .227 .280 .507 at A Lexington |
Worst second-round pick this century |
| 3 | Thomas Manzella | SS | .264 .324 .339 .663 split between High A Salem & AA Corpus |
Baseball America says Manzella is our best defensive infielder |
| 3 (S'wich) | Joshua Lindblom | P |
|
Never Signed; went to U Tennessee |
| 4 | Josh Flores | OF | .279.345 .422 .767 split between High A Salem & AA Corpus |
Kicked ass at Salem; not so good at Corpus |
| 5 | Billy Hart | 3B | .385 .451 .305 .836 at High A Salem |
Won Carolina League Batting Crown |
| 6 | Brandon Barnes | OF | .251 .336 .459 .795 at Short A Tri-City |
|
| 7 | Timothy Johnson | SS | .186 .273 .248 .521 at Rookie Greeneville |
Has played three years of Rookie ball--you NEVER see that. Not particularly good defensively either |
| 8 | Koby Clemens | 3B | .252 .344 .412 .755 at A Lexington |
That switch to catcher previously dismissed still might make it work for him |
| 9 | Jordan Meaker | P |
|
Never Signed; went to Dallas Baptist |
| 10 | Allen Langdon | OF |
|
Released in June '07. Injuries took a toll as he never progressed past Rookie Greeneville |
| 11 | Cory Lapinski | P |
|
Released in March '07, having reached Short A Tri-City |
| 12 | Tip Fairchild | P | 10.29 .214 .514 at AA Corpus |
Made only two starts for Corpus before blowing out his elbow |
| 13 | Eric King | SS | .229.308 .291 .599 at High A Salem |
|
| 14 | Mark Ori | 1B | .272.350 .395 .746 at High A Salem |
|
| 15 | Eric Sheridan | P |
|
Released in June '06; pitched Single A ball in '07 with the A's |
0 recs |
10 comments
Comments
Rough draft
by Shamus on Nov 25, 2007 8:44 AM CST reply actions 0 recs
Koby
by Stros Bro on Nov 25, 2007 3:47 PM CST reply actions 0 recs
Shouldn't there be someone...
That's a sad, sad chart.
Other names drafted after the Astros first pick and already in the bigs: Travis Buck (A's - #36), Clay Buchholz (No Hitter for the Sawx - #42), Garrett Olsen (Orioles - #48), Yunel Escobar (Braves - #75), and Micah Ownings (D-backs, #83)... that's just the first few rounds.
And those are just names I recognize.
by TexSkins on Nov 25, 2007 4:15 PM CST reply actions 0 recs
I remember being ticked
I recall being even more disgusted when Bogusevic got hammered in the regional playoffs and Manzella was a non-factor.
Every so often a writer will tout these two as future major league stars.
They may be.
I'll believe it when (if) I see it.
Put me in the camp that's thankful Astros changed scouting directors.
by Joe in Birmingham on Nov 25, 2007 8:33 PM CST reply actions 0 recs
I doubt they will be stars....
I thought this passage from Richard Justice's Nov. 10 blog in the HC was interesting:
"David Lakey recently was inducted into the Texas Scouts Associaton Hall of Fame. In eight years as scouting director of the Astros, he--and his assistant, Pat Murphy--drafted 35 big leaguers (with another three to five still in the pipeline). The MLB average is 2.5 players per draft. Lakey almost doubled that number, but he and Murphy were sent packing. Do you think the Astros regret those decisions?
When Ed Wade interviewed for the GM job, he told Drayton McLane that one bad draft can set an organization back three years. The Astros had about three bad ones in a row under Paul Ricciarini. Wade's first important hire was to replace Ricciarini with Bobby Heck."
by clack on Nov 25, 2007 9:26 PM CST up reply actions 0 recs
More Info
Number of Teams with a pick from '05 having reached the majors - 20/30
Number of picks that reached the majors taken before Bogusevic - 10/26
So, basically half the teams dealing with a pick worse than our best have hit paydirt.
Not to exonerate our scouting staff or try to nominate Ricciarini for sainthood, but I was a little surprised at the vehement response in the comments.
by rastronomicals on Nov 28, 2007 5:35 PM CST reply actions 0 recs
Richard Justice has been blaming...
"The Astros built a consistent winner through their farm system. Few teams worked the now-defunct draft-and-follow system or the Venezuelan market as well, and they also had a knack for finding quality, low-cost college seniors. But the talent has dried up this decade, and Houston has had to invest heavily on free agents to keep winning. That approach has proved costly, not only in terms of big league salaries but also in its affect on the club's drafts.
In three of the last five drafts, the Astros have forfeited their first-round pick as free-agent compensation. McLane has become more reluctant to offer arbitration to his own free agents, so only once during that period has Houston received bonus choices of its own. He also has been increasingly unwilling to buck MLB's slot recommendations. All three of these factors resulted in a disastrous draft in 2007.
By signing Carlos Lee and Woody Williams as Type A free agents, the Astros surrendered their first two draft choices. Offering arbitration to three of their own Type A free agents--Aubrey Huff, Andy Pettitte and Russ Springer--was a low-risk proposition that could have yielded three first-round picks and three supplemental first-rounders, but Houston declined to do so. The Astros couldn't try to compensate by drafting players with high price tags because McLane refused to exceed MLB's guidelines.
Houston thought it had signing parameters in place with its first two choices, third baseman Derek Dietrich (third round) and righthander Brett Eibner (fourth), as well as righty Chad Bettis (eighth). But they all asked for more than slot money and wound up opting for college over pro ball. The Astros spent just $1.584 million on the draft, $3.6 million below the average of the other 29 teams.
They also haven't been aggressive internationally, especially since former director of Venezuelan scouting and development Andres Reiner left the organization in February 2006. Reiner, a pioneer in establishing a Venezuelan pipeline, helped sign players such as Bobby Abreu, Carlos Guillen and Johan Santana, as well as the club's current top pitching prospect, Felipe Paulino. The Astros haven't brought in any comparable foreign talents in recent years."
by clack on Nov 29, 2007 7:58 AM CST up reply actions 0 recs
Speaking of Venezuela
Because of Reiner--who was a genius at what he did--the Astros were first (and for a long time best) in Venezuela.
Now, because of some of the comments that Hugo Chavez has made--and face it, because of his all around flakiness--some teams are backing out.
The Astros remain in Venezuela as other teams take off, and this is a risk that could end up paying off handsomely if Chavez stays reasonable, or that could set us back further if he does not.
by rastronomicals on Dec 1, 2007 11:00 AM CST up reply actions 0 recs
Interesting...
by clack on Dec 1, 2007 6:05 PM CST up reply actions 0 recs
Can Ed Wade Lure Andres Reiner Back?
Reiner is 70 and currently working for Tampa Bay Rays, but he still lives in Houston. I'd imagine his days of scouting Venezuela are done, but his contacts must be so great that some protege of his (with his advice and his reputation) could rejuvenate the Latin American scouting and player development operations. (I say that without knowing the state of the Astros operations down there - it may be okay)
by Joe in Birmingham on Dec 1, 2007 10:34 PM CST up reply actions 0 recs

by 





















