Searching for the Astros Skipper: The Finalists
Surprised? Not really. Late Wednesday, the four finalists for the Astros managerial opening were released through multiple sources here, here and here. Interestingly enough, none of the three news outlets had the same list of names, except Acta. More thoughts after the jump...
As I said, this is hardly surprising, since the list included one candidate with serious ties to the organization (Acta), one from a top-flight organization that Wade admires (Mills) and one possible internal candidate (maybe Clark?). The blogosphere is already abuzz that this is a move designed to keep Cleveland from landing Acta. If that's the case, though, why interview all these people? One theory that's been bandied about this blog in the last few days is that the Astros intend to bring on one or more of the candidates for roles other than manager.That makes sense on some levels, especially if the front-runner is the relatively-young Acta.
Still, isn't it the least bit surprising that Drayton hasn't been more involved to this point? Everything we've ever heard about his executive style says he's integral in all decision making. Why did he "leave the country" during the first round of interviews? Were these just courtesy calls to make Wade's friends and colleagues happy? Probably not, but we know with Drayton's inclusion that these are serious interviews now.
Let's discuss the candidates a little. If we believe the four listed by Mark Berman, the fan vote is definitely split between Garner and Acta. Since Clark was contacted by the Chronicle and said he hadn't heard about a second interview, I tend to give little credence to that list though. Instead, we know of two confirmed candidates in Mills and Acta. Mills would seem to have the edge in experience while Acta has the sabermetric-savvy attitude and is an easier sell to the Latino players on the Astros (as one Cleveland columnist pointed out here). Mills, however, has been through playoff battles with the Red Sox and has seen how to compete with a big budget and big markets. My vote, between those two, falls with Acta, simply because I want someone who's not going to have to learn on the job. Garner, if he's a finalist, would be too easy and has the same problem Clark ultimately will. Both embody the status quo of the team right now, and that needs to be shaken up.
We'll keep updating as more news filters out. With it being so close to the World Series, unless the Astros are planning on naming someone by this weekend, it may be a while before one of these guys gets the job.
0 recs |
11 comments
|
Comments
any chance
we can get like acta to be manager, and mills to do something else in org. (Maybe first base coach?)
bring someone like ausmus as bench coach…maybe like bogar for 3b coach?
by EveryHoustonTeamRox! on Oct 21, 2009 7:49 PM CDT reply actions 0 recs
Wild Idea
Here’s a totally wild idea. It’s so wild, it’s probably silly.
What if Drayton splits the baby and does a Mack Brown / Will Muschamp arrangement.
Bring Garner in as manager, with Acta as bench. Garner gets two or three years with an absolute hard end date. Acta is anointed as the successor-in-waiting.
Garner boosts the team morale, cohesion, and transitions the team from old to new. Then, he hands the reins over to Acta for the Astros future and rides off into the sunset.
Best of both worlds? Or unrealistic?
by pel on Oct 21, 2009 9:10 PM CDT reply actions 0 recs
seems unlikely to me.
Drayton doesn’t seem like the type to do something that untraditional.
by clack on Oct 21, 2009 9:56 PM CDT up reply actions 0 recs
the problem I see
(beyond the sort of roadblocks clack is talking about) is that neither Garner or Acta would seem to be happy in that sort of role.
Garner is basically given a job that he knows he will lose no matter how well he does. Why would he do that?
And Acta is put in a subordinate position, even though he has experience in running an ML team. It’s practically an insult.
Your friendly neighborhood Dream Shake mod.
by Only_A_Lad on Oct 21, 2009 10:03 PM CDT up reply actions 0 recs
Plus Acta would have to give up a possible manager position with the Indians (where he is a finalist) in order to accept an Astros’ promise of a manager job later. According to Rosenthal at FoxSports, the Indians and Astros are competitive in their pursuit of Acta….and Rosenthal suggests that McLane competitive instincts may cause him to speed up a decision on Acta in order to keep the Indians from making a preemptive move.
by clack on Oct 21, 2009 10:31 PM CDT up reply actions 0 recs
I’ve had that same feeling, and I’m going to take a gander that if it is in fact Acta he will be named manager before the World Series is over.
by timmy_ on Oct 22, 2009 12:18 PM CDT up reply actions 0 recs
Where's Bogar and Mackanin ?
I recommeded something similar to pel’s idea yesterday. My approach however was to make Bogar manager and hire the experienced managers like Garner, Mackanin, Acta as coaches.
Astros fan for life
by Joe in Birmingham on Oct 21, 2009 9:20 PM CDT reply actions 0 recs
My preference is Acta. I admit that the experience with Cooper makes me react by wanting the Anti-Cooper? :)
Mills would be my second choice (assuming Fox26 has the 4 finalists right), because I would prefer a clean break from the past.
It’s sheer speculation to wonder what happened to Bogar, Mackanin, etc. It could be what happened in the interviews, or it could be that they weren’t high on the list to begin with. Several articles say that Acta has impressed the Astros in interviews.
by clack on Oct 22, 2009 8:27 AM CDT reply actions 0 recs
Perhaps the problem with Bogar is that he’s too young to relate to Brocail, Coste, and Moehler? Maybe they can make Bogar the bench coach. As for the finalists, would like to see Acta get the job.
by jmike on Oct 22, 2009 9:13 AM CDT reply actions 0 recs
Is it an issue that Manny Acta never played in the major leagues?
by jmike on Oct 22, 2009 9:17 AM CDT up reply actions 0 recs
I don’t think so. Jim Leyland played 10 years in the minors but never made it as a player to the majors. Some other managers who have good reputations had minimal experience in the majors—like Tommy Lasorda and Tony LaRussa. LaRussa was mostly a minor league player, with occasional call ups, who averaged about 15 games in each season he was called up. The Astros, themselves, suggested that Acta would be better off on the “manager track” rather than continuing his minor league career.
by clack on Oct 22, 2009 9:46 AM CDT up reply actions 0 recs

by 




















