Roster Management
Each ML team has 25 roster spots. Those are valuable spots. The idea is to have 25 players who contribute something to the team, or at least don't hurt the team.
In '07, Astros roster management was terrible. Too much nonproductive deadwood that did more to hurt the team than help it: Woody Williams, O. Palmeiro, Borkowski, Moehler (actually, he was kind of a neutral, did OK as a mopup guy, but useless in game-on-the-line situations), Lane, Ensberg, Ausmus (offensively). Biggio as leadoff and no-range 2B didn't help, either, but let's not get back into that. "Can't-hit-a-lick" Everett.
Give some marks for improvement this year: Williams, Palmeiro, Lane, Ensberg, Biggio, Everett gone.
But there's still too much deadwood: Borkowski & Moehler remain. (Why carry ANY relief pitchers, much less 2 of them, who can't be trusted in game-on-the-line situations?) "O." Palmeiro has been replaced by ".063" Cruz Jr. Ausmus remains as an offensive liability.
Additionally, it's wasting one roster spot to carry both Blum & Loretta. They're the same player: old, limited range on defense, no power on offense, will hit .230 or less. They fill the same role -- playing multiple infield positions on defense, can contribute an occasional timely hit off the bench on offense -- and are simply redundant. Of the two, Blum's the keeper, because he's a switch-hitter and is the 3rd catcher. Admittedly, that situation is not totally Wade's fault. They offered Loretta arbitration hoping he'd decline & they'd get a sandwich pick for him as a Type B free agent. Unfortunately, the other 25 teams correctly evaluated his age and faded talent and no one offered him a job, so we're stuck with him.
That's really the key to evaluating these players. Would any of the other 25 teams pick them up? No one would take Cruz, Jr., who's already been dumped by the Giants, Dodgers and Padres in recent years. The Astros are wasting a roster spot on him only because ... well, we all know why. I think Jose Sr. could outhit Jose Jr. if they swapped positions. Moehler would clear waivers. Some team would probably take a foolish flyer on Borkowski, but maybe we'd get lucky & it would be a team in the NL Central so we could crush HR's off him.
Time to bring up some of the AA guys (there's little talent in RR) & see if they can do better than the deadwood we've got. They could hardly do worse. Einerston or Iorg could hit .163 & be 100 points better than Cheito. Tommy Manzella could hit .230 and be better (defensively) than Loretta. Even a journeyman like Paz or Sadler would be better than Cruz Jr.
Until we get the deadwood that other teams won't touch off our roster, we're going to keep having washed-up, mediocre players losing games for us. Cooper's basically competing with a 21-man roster against smarter teams (Exhibit A: the Cardinals) who are productively using 25. Over the course of the season, that will sink you.
0 recs |
17
comments
Comments
I agree with you on most points
I can’t fault the Astros for giving Cruz Jr. a chance in spring training and then giving him a roster spot based on how good he did during the spring… but he’s been pathetic during the regular season and shouldn’t be on the roster if he keeps this up.
I’m totally on board with Moehler(and pretty much on board about Borkowski). If you don’t trust a pitcher to have him pitch when it matters… there is no point in having him there.. you shouldn’t be paying someone to just be available in mop up roles.. you could let prospect do that.
Good stuff
Go 'Stros!
by Stros Bro on May 1, 2008 11:01 AM CDT 0 recs
I agree with some of the comments.
I don’t agree that you can’t keep both Blum and Loretta on the roster, though. You need two utility infielders and two extra outfielders.The redundancy is required. Without that flexibility, the team can’t withstand short term injuries, suspensions, or position changes in extra innings. Loretta wasn’t “unwanted” by other teams. He just asked for too much money, and then decided he could get more in arbitration with the Astros. The Yankees, Rockies, and Padres were all looking to sign him if he had been cheaper. Loretta’s salary is an impediment to cutting him also…the Astros still have to pay him. I’m not unhappy with either Loretta or Blum (and I wasn’t wild about signing Blum to begin with).
Einerston and Iorg are not ready for the majors. They have to perform better in AA first. But I do think it is time to cut ties with Cruz, Jr….something which Cooper may find hard to do, given his friendship with Cruz, Sr. If nothing else, I would call up Victor Diaz from AAA. He isn’t tearing it up, but he is hitting the best of the Round Rock outfielders. He is only 26 and he has proven that he has power at the major league level (though he K’s too much). I also think the Astros should scour the waiver wires for reserve outfielders, or even seek a minor trade, and perhaps find a better choice for the bench that way. MLBTraderumors.com suggested that the Astros should pick up Jason Botts who was recently waived by the Rangers as a replacement for Cruz, Jr. Since I don’t know much about Botts, I can’t say if that is good or bad advice…but it is the type of search that can be done.
by clack on May 1, 2008 12:15 PM CDT 0 recs
Mentioned Jason Botts, but said...
I don’t much about him. And then I ran across this Rangers’ blog discussing the waiver of Botts.
http://www.newbergreport.com/article1.asp
Interesting that he compares the treatment of Botts to the Rangers letting Mike Lamb go.
by clack on
May 1, 2008 12:32 PM CDT
up
0 recs
Not a bad suggestion (Botts)
We missed a similar available outfielder last week—Gabe Gross of Milwaukee, who’s been a valuable pinch hitter in recent years (Lefty off the bench, like O. Palmeiro was before he turned 65 a couple of years ago.) The TB Rays, short of outfielders, picked him up for almost nothing … a throwaway Class A prospect.
I agree there’s no clear choice among the Astro minor-leaguers, and that none except the journeymen in AA are tearing it up this season. But could any of them do worse than Cheito?
Heck, Botts at .158 is hitting more than TWICE as high as Cruz. That’s sad.
There is a bright side to the '08 season.
Barry Bonds & Roger Clemens are out of baseball.
by maris61 on
May 1, 2008 1:12 PM CDT
up
0 recs
I agree with both of y'all
Hate to see Cheito doing so poorly, it was a good story, but I’m in favor of shorter leashes after watching Lane and Ensberg for so long. And I’m with clack—he’s “not unhappy” with Loretta, but I actually like the guy. How does a career .296 hitter get categorized as “hit[ting] .230 or less”? He may be aging and overpaid (who isn’t, when you think about it), but his average has actually gone up the last three years.
75% of the Earth's surface is covered by water. . . the other 25% by Michael Bourn
by Danyah on
May 1, 2008 3:23 PM CDT
up
0 recs
Loretta
is hitting .216 at present, so I think saying he’s “hitting .230 or less” is fair. His career avg., much like Biggio’s career avg. last year, doesn’t mean much to me. What can he do for the Astros in 2008?
If he could hit .280 or so off the bench and as an occasional fill-in starter (his last 3 years were .280, .285 and .287), that would be OK, but I doubt he’s capable of doing that again. He has come up with some timely hits on occasion, I grant you, but I think his best days are getting pretty far behind him. And his defensive range is atrocious. And no power. If the Astros could find a team to take him in a trade for a prospect, they should jump at it.
And who’s not aging and overpaid? Me. I’m aging for sure, but I’m not overpaid.
There is a bright side to the '08 season.
Barry Bonds & Roger Clemens are out of baseball.
by maris61 on
May 1, 2008 4:23 PM CDT
up
0 recs
Sure
He’s hitting .230 or less right now, but I just take issue with the “will hit” part of your post. You may very well be correct, as he certainly declined in the last half of last season. You are convinced that his current performance is predictive of season-long performance. But does anybody really think Tejada is going to hit .345 all year? I don’t, although it would be nice.
And with “aging and overpaid,” I meant ballplayers. I think they’re all overpaid, personally.
75% of the Earth's surface is covered by water. . . the other 25% by Michael Bourn
by Danyah on
May 2, 2008 5:05 AM CDT
up
0 recs
Come to think of it
In addition to Lamb, didn’t the Rangers also give up on Carlos Pena & Adrian Gonzales?
Why not try an ex-Ranger … they may be slightly better than our farm teams, though it’s a close call.
There is a bright side to the '08 season.
Barry Bonds & Roger Clemens are out of baseball.
by maris61 on May 1, 2008 1:28 PM CDT 0 recs
I may have to correct that
Just looked at the RR Express stats. Other than Victor Diaz (.296, but little power) and J.R. House (.284, catcher, no room for him with Towles-Ausmus-Q ahead in line),
THERE ARE NO REGULARS IN RR HITTING OVER .240.
Gee that’s pathetic.
There is a bright side to the '08 season.
Barry Bonds & Roger Clemens are out of baseball.
by maris61 on
May 1, 2008 1:38 PM CDT
up
0 recs
Diaz HAS power....
but it seems to come in streaky spurts, like Luke Scott. I think he will show some home run power soon. He had a .520 slugging % in the PCL last year.
by clack on
May 1, 2008 2:24 PM CDT
up
0 recs
Surprisingly
Victor Diaz was released on Thursday after the Express’ game. Gorneault is the remaining outfielder on the RR roster with decent numbers.
by clack on
May 2, 2008 3:29 PM CDT
up
0 recs
the last thing we need
is to have Einerston and Iorg, some of our few position player prospects that might actually project to the major leagues, slowing turning into Jason Lane on our bench.
i agree on some points (re: Moehler, Borkowski, Cruz Jr.), but the big question is, what are our choices? getting Wiggy back will help, just by adding another position player (coulda used one last night), and i can’t imagine Byrdak doesn’t stay up, so one of those two gotta go.
i really wonder what they’re going to do with Cheito. will they give him another start soon? i can’t imagine Coop turning to him in a pressure situation anytime soon. is he going to come around batting only in low-pressure PH spots? i doubt it.
our bench has been atrocious so far this season. we’re batting a pathetic 0.086 in pinch hit situations, with an OPS of 0.305. kinda makes you miss Lamb, Scott, and even OP, huh?
by littlevisigoth on May 1, 2008 3:52 PM CDT 0 recs
Ditto
Lamb and Scott.. Yes. OP, not so much
Go 'Stros!
by Stros Bro on
May 1, 2008 7:14 PM CDT
up
0 recs
i was being sarcastic
although honestly, if Cruz and OP were the only two people on our bench right now and it was tied late, i’d turn to OP to start the rally. i was just illustrating how aweful Cruz has been to this point in the season. DEAD LAST in all hitters in the MLB with at least 25 AB’s (that’s 363 guys now).
by littlevisigoth on
May 2, 2008 8:55 AM CDT
up
0 recs
oops
didn’t reread my own comment. still, as aweful as OP was last year, i’d think he could manage better than 0.086 as a pinch hitter.
by littlevisigoth on
May 2, 2008 8:57 AM CDT
up
0 recs
more cruz
i think (and maybe this is just blind optimism) that a great deal of his struggles can be attributed to complete lack of playing and spotty pinch-hitting chances. when he played regularly in spring training (and yes, i know it’s spring training), he hit really well. it is great to have a switch hitter off the bench, but he needs to learn to be a good option off the bench- and i believe that is probably the toughest role in all of baseball. palmeiro wasn’t a great hitter, but he did occasionally come up with big off the bench clutch hits.
however, all that said – i’d KILL to have cruz gone and lamb back. but i am glad to see him getting more regular playing time in minnesota (even if his numbers currently aren’t up to par).
by exit53 on May 2, 2008 2:53 PM CDT 0 recs
















